Why Is My French Press Hard To Press: 3 Causes & Fixes

A picture of a french press with the text why your french press is hard to push down

French Press coffee can be bold and delicious. However, a common problem with this brewing method is that the French Press can be hard to press down. In my opinion, French Press plungers usually get stuck from too fine a coffee grind or a low-quality grinder. However, there are other possibilities, and I’ll explore them and their solutions in this article.

Whether it’s time to upgrade your grinder or you just need help dialing in the right size, I am confident you will solve your French Press clogging issues by the end of this article!

**Best of Brewing is supported by our readers, and we sometimes earn a commission through the affiliate links on our website.**

French Press Clogging: Here’s the 101

While too fine a grind or too much coffee can make a French Press hard to push down, the primary cause of this resistance is the filter getting clogged. These fine coffee particles (what coffee pros call fines) exist even when you use a coarse grind. You can avoid this clogging by keeping your French Press clean and pushing slowly. The gentle force will keep the fines from clogging your filter screen while plunging.

For me, I was producing too many fines because I used to own a low-quality blade grinder. In this situation, no amount of cleaning will fix your issue. My tip: go with a burr grinder instead!

Why Is My French Press So Hard To Push Down: Primary Causes & Fixes

Pushing gently may have already fixed your French Press issues. However, let’s examine the detailed causes and fixes for why a French Press could be hard to push down.

A picture of a french press with text explaining why a French Press is hard to press down and how to fix it

See Also: How To Choose The Best French Press Coffee Maker

Clogged Plunger Screen/Filter

One reason your plunger screen and filter could be clogging is that fine coffee grounds and grit are building up over time. As annoying as cleaning a French Press can be, it can definitely cause your plunger to push down slowly. Also, a dirty French Press plunger will put off flavors into your coffee!

Best Overall
Bodum Chambord French Press Coffee Maker
4.7

Features:

  • Classic, simple, and elegant design
  • 34-ounce capacity
  • Stainless steel frame
  • Three-part metal mesh filter

However, another reason could be that fine coffee particles are clogging up the pores in the filter screen. This clogging is less common with metal screens than it is with cloth filters, similar to the problem of slow pour-overs.

To avoid the coffee fines from clogging your filter, push the plunger slowly and gently. You can even wait 30 seconds after an initial shallow push so the coffee grounds naturally sink.

Note: Your grinder may be creating too many fines if it is low quality or the burrs need replacement. Read about cheap vs. expensive grinders for more details.

Grind Is Too Fine

As a full immersion brewing method, French Press can easily over-extract (aka those bitter coffee flavors!) Also, the metal screen on a French Press can’t stop fine particles from making it into your brew. So, a coarse grind is the way for proper French Press extraction. I tend to aim for a grind size that resembles bread crumbs.

If you’re familiar with the Chemex dripper, think of something slightly coarser than that method.

See Also: French Press vs Pour Over Coffee: Which Method Is Better For You?

There’s Too Much Coffee

My preferred French Press recipe uses a 1:12 ratio—12 grams/milliliters of water for every one gram of coffee—which is a stronger ratio than many recipes. A more typical ratio is 1:15 or 1:16. I just happen to love the bolder taste that syncs up with French Press immersion flavors.

However, using more coffee like this may cause resistance when you push the plunger down. You might consider using less coffee to see if that fixes your problem. Also, remember that you can plunge halfway and gently pour the coffee into a different container. There’s nothing magical about pushing all the way to the bottom!

Rare Causes Making a French Press Hard to Press

While the above reasons are the main cause of a French Press being hard to push down, here are some rarer factors to keep in mind:

  • Grinder creating too many fines: Even the best coffee grinders create fines, but low-quality grinders (especially blade grinders) struggle much more with this issue. The only fix is investing in a better burr grinder.
  • Pushing too hard: If you plunge with too much force, the fine particles will clog up your screen. Sometimes, I only push the plunger halfway down and then wait 30-60 seconds before slowly decanting the coffee into a different container.
  • Short Brew Time: When hot water first hits freshly roasted coffee, it degases and causes bubbles/foam. If you try to plunge too quickly, this degassing causes resistance. Wait 4-5 minutes before plunging to give the coffee time to settle.

Final Thought on Why A French Press Is Hard to Press Down

Hopefully, you now understand why a French Press sometimes gets stuck and have enough information to fix this issue once and for all. French Press brewing can be wonderful, but, like any brewing method, it also has its downsides.

Lastly, if you love the full immersion richness of French Press coffee but dislike the coffee grit and clogging, consider siphon coffee which combines the best of immersion and filter brewing!

Want more coffee tips directly in your inbox? Sign up for our newsletter here.

FAQs

Should a French press plunger go all the way down?

While the grounds are steeping, the plunger should sit at the top of the brew, perhaps just below the water’s surface to keep the grounds submerged. However, after approximately four minutes of steeping, you should press a French Press plunger all the way down to the bottom.

Why does my French press get stuck?

The two most common reasons that your French Press gets stuck are that your grind is too fine or you are using too much coffee. Either use a coarser grind or try using less coffee to see if that fixes your problem. Alternatively, some French presses with a mesh screen might be clogged.

Why is my French Press hard to press with fresh coffee?

If the French Press is hard to push down only with fresh coffee, the extra degassing is likely causing resistance as you push. You should wait 4-5 minutes before plunging. Also, consider breaking the crust and allowing the grounds to naturally settle before plunging.

Why doesn’t my French press plunger go to the bottom?

While the French Press plunger should go to the bottom, there will always be some space at the bottom occupied by the used coffee grounds. If, however, your plunger gets stuck earlier than this “almost bottom” point, consider using a coarser grind, dosing less coffee, or giving your French Press a proper cleaning.

Show 3 Comments

3 Comments

Comments are closed