SUMMARY: If your pour over coffee is watery and weak tasting, the primary reason is most likely a wide brewing ratio, meaning you used either too much water or too little coffee. Other possible reaons include the grind being too coarse, a low water temperature, improper pouring technique, or inadequate blooming time. While all pour over drippers are unique, achieving a strong/flavorful brew on any of them requires the right grind size, heating water to 199-205°F, a careful pouring method, and using fresh, quality beans.
Brewing manual pour over coffee takes time and attention, so I can understand the frustration of failing to achieve the rich flavors that you expect. So what causes a pour over coffee to be weak and have a watery texture/flavor?
Luckily, this common issue has a relatively easy fix, including other standard pour-over techniques that can contribute to watery coffee. In this article, I’ll cover:
- Dialing in the brewing ratio for pour over coffee
- The significance of grind size in achieving the desired coffee strength
- How water temperature affects extraction
- The proper pouring technique and its impact on flavor
- The right way to bloom
So, continue reading to learn how to make a bold pour over and equip yourself with common fixes for pour over troubleshooting situations.
Why Is My Pour Over Coffee So Watery? Here’s the 101
While many factors can cause a coffee pour over to be weak and watery, the primary reason is an incorrect coffee-to-water ratio. If there is not enough coffee or too much water, even the perfect brewing technique will create a diluted drink. For both pour over and drip coffee brewing, I recommend a 1:15 or 1:16 ratio, ideally measured with a gram scale. Without a scale, measure by volume with 1 tablespoon of coffee for each 4 ounces of water.
Is Pour Over Coffee Naturally Weaker?
I wanted to clear up some confusion about pour over brewing and how it compares to immersion methods such as French Press and AeroPress. While it is true that pour over brews comparatively have a lighter body and more flavor clarity, these factors are different from strength. Pour over coffee is not naturally weaker unless you brew it incorrectly. With a proper brewing ratio and technique, pour over coffee can be just as strong as other brewing methods, but have extraction flavors unique to the method.
Other Causes of a Weak Pour Over Coffee & How To Fix It
If the paragraph above was new information, then I would bet that an incorrect brewing ratio caused your coffee to be watery. However, other factors can contribute to weak-tasting coffee.
The Grind: Size Matters
Grind size affects the extraction for all brewing methods. Finer grinds have more surface area and extract faster, while coarser grinds do the opposite. However, with pour over brewing, grind size plays an even more crucial role because it also has an indirect effect on brewing time.
Like many aspects of life, the primary idea is balance. You want the grind to be fine enough to extract a strong flavor, but not so fine that you over-extract into bitter and drying flavors. Generally, if you find your brew to be disappointingly watery, your grind is likely too coarse.
Read More: The Best Coffee Grinders at Every Budget
Also, in terms of precisely altering grind size, you need to use a burr grinder and avoid blade models, which produce uneven grinds and cannot accurately adjust to different sizes. When adjusting your grind to be finer for a stronger brew, try a little bit at a time to avoid the issues of long brew times and over-extraction.
Lastly, each pour over coffee maker requires a specific range of grind sizes. For example, my Hario V60 often brews perfectly with a grind setting of 15 on my Baratza Virtuoso, while the Chemex requires a coarse grind from 20-23.
Water Temperature
According to the Specialty Coffee Association’s best brewing practices, the ideal brewing temperature is 200°F (93.0°C) with a 5°F flexibility on either side (3°C.) So, this means that the ideal pour over brewing temperature should be 195-205°F, or 90-96°C.
However, keep in mind that water temperature lowers drastically as it leaves the kettle, and even more so as it mixes with the coffee. If you environment is cold, this effect can be even more extreme. While low water temperature should not cause a drastic weakness in your pour over, it is a factor worth double checking.
For experiments, I will sometimes use my Thermapen and keep it in the coffee slurry to see how the brewing temperature changes throughout the process. Give it a try, the results will surprise you!
Pouring Technique: A Balancing Act
Water temperature will not mean much if you do not use the proper pouring technique. A gentle and balanced pour is essential in reaching the optimal extraction, which in turn influences the overall strength and taste of your coffee.
Features:
- Stovetop pour-over coffee kettle
- 301 18/8 stainless steel material & 1.0 Liter boiling capacity
- Built-in thermometer
- Precision pour spout with fluted tip & counterbalanced handle
- Used by Brewers Cup Champions
The goal is to maintain a consistent flow and water level throughout the brewing process. Use a circular motion starting from the center, moving outward, then back toward the center. This method ensures that all grounds are evenly saturated, contributing to a well-balanced brew, rather than one that’s weak or overly bitter.
Remember to avoid pouring too quickly or aggressively. Aggressive pouring can sometimes cause over-extraction from too much agitation and clogging of the filter. However, aggressive pouring can also rush the brewing process. When water passes through the grounds too quickly, it doesn’t have enough time to pick up the full range of flavors.
Pour over brewing is about taking your time and having patience, so I do not recommend it during a rushed morning! For me, I save pour-overs for those slower mornings where I can enjoy the meditative process.
Blooming
The coffee bloom at the beginning of a pour-over brew is an integral step that should not be overlooked. During this phase, you pour a small amount of hot water (3X the amount of coffee) over the grounds and wait for 30-45 seconds to allow the coffee to degas. This release of carbon dioxide prepares the coffee for a more even extraction. A bloom also extends the brew time so that you can get a stronger flavor.
So if you forgot about blooming, it could definitely be the cause of a watery coffee!
Other Tips for Perfecting Your Pour Over
Besides understanding and controlling the basic pour over variables above, mastering this method to get a rich and flavorful brew requires a deeper understanding. While it can be helpful to think of these variables as separate, they are all interconnected and play off of each other.
Yes, they all have a direct effect on extraction. For example, a finer grind will have more surface area and extract more. However, a finer grind will also slow down the flow of water, increasing the brew time, meaning an even higher extraction. Similarly, if you do not use enough coffee, water will flow too fast, and there will be two reasons that your pour over tastes watery and weak.
Some standard tips include:
- Like a scientist, adjust one variable at a time.
- Stirring the coffee during the bloom can greatly affect evenness and strength.
- Use high-quality/good-tasting filtered water(or Third Wave Water.)
However, to become a true master of pour over brewing, you must see the forest for the trees, or, understand that all of these brewing parameters are tightly connected. Yes, you have to perfect each step. However, understanding the harmony of all these factors becomes about balance: the goal is to find the balance of dosage, grind size, and pouring technique that creates the perfect brew time and extraction.
Choice of Coffee Beans: The Flavor Foundation
Needless to say, your choice of coffee beans will have a crucial effect on the strength, caffeine level, and overall flavor of your pour over and drip coffee. So, first and foremost, buy fresh coffee in whole bean form and make sure you store it properly. Lastly, you should grind immediately before brewing to preserve freshness.
In terms of strength and flavor, it’s also good to know how roast level affects things. When considering bean choice, also think about the roast level. Lighter roasts tend to have a brighter, more acidic flavor. Single-origin light roasts can especially have subtle fruit flavors and floral tea-like aromas. The subtleties of these coffees can give the impression of a weaker, even when that is not the case. However, you can also increase the dosage to get a more perceptible strength.
Darker roasts, however, bring out the flavors of the roast itself and can introduce a smokier, sometimes bittersweet taste. A medium roast typically offers a balance between acidity and body, making it a popular choice. However, the perfect roast is ultimately subjective and should align with your personal preference.
Lastly, the processing method (washed, natural, honey) also leaves its mark on the beans, affecting the final taste of your coffee. Natural processed coffees will be especially noticeable, so it is good to know the details of the beans you are buying!
Pour Over FAQs
Here are the answers to common questions and issues people have with pour over brewing, especially dealing with watery/weak brews.
Why is my pour-over coffee coming out so weak?
If your pour over coffee isn’t strong, it could be due to a suboptimal brewing ratio, a grind size that’s too coarse, or a water temperature that’s too low. Using a finer grind, measuring your water and coffee grounds accurately, and ensuring your water is between 199-205°F (93-96°C) can help achieve a stronger brew.
What is the ideal pour over coffee ratio?
For most situations, the perfect pour-over coffee ratio is 1:16, which is 1 gram of coffee for every 16 grams (or milliliters) of water. Use a scale, because you cannot accurately get this ideal ratio when measuring by volume since coffee varies in density based on its origin and roast level. Lastly, there is flexibility with pour-over ratios, so experimenting can help you achieve the perfect extraction.
How does grind size affect pour over coffee taste?
The grind size can greatly influence the taste of pour-over coffee because it affects the surface area of coffee exposed to water and therefore the extraction rate. Grind size also affects brew time, since water percolates more slowly through smaller particles. A medium-coarse grind is generally recommended for a pour over, as it allows for a balanced extraction, producing a full-flavored brew without excessive bitterness or a weak, under-extracted taste.
What roast should I use for pour over coffee?
When choosing a roast for pour over coffee, it ultimately depends on personal preference. However, lighter to medium roasts often work well because they tend to highlight the unique flavors and acidity of the coffee, which pour over brewing can accentuate. However, have fun experimenting with different roasts to find the profile that suits your taste the best!
Conclusion: The Path to a Flawless Pour Over
Hopefully, you now know what to do when your pour over coffee looks watery and tastes weak. The interplay of each variable can be confusing, but remember to:
- Use the correct brewing ratio
- Select a grind size that is medium-coarse to optimize extraction time and flavor complexity.
- Heat water to the ideal range of 199-205°F (93-96°C) to effectively extract the coffee’s solubles.
- Bloom at the beginning to extend brew time and enhance extraction.
- Use a gentle and consistent pouring technique, ideally with a gooseneck kettle.
- Choose high-quality, fresh beans and grind them right before brewing.
Pour over brewing can be frustrating and there is a learning curve. So have patience and pay attention to the details. I recommend writing down the recipe and keeping track of your brews so you can understand how each variable affects the extraction.
Get in touch with your experiences, and I hope these tips help your pour-over brews taste delicious!
Want more coffee tips directly in your inbox? Sign up for our newsletter here.
Pingback: How To Make Pour Over Coffee: Complete Guide For Any Dripper